Sports
Replacing Idrissa Gueye: Analysing contenders, and who the data says Everton should target
The last time Everton attempted to replace Idrissa Gueye, it did not go well.
Given his impact and work rate at the time, the Merseyside club accepted in summer 2019 that they needed a couple of new additions to fill the void created by his departure to Paris Saint-Germain — a sound theory on paper that fell apart when it came to the actual recruitment of those players.
Ivory Coast international Jean-Philippe Gbamin was full of promise but blighted by injuries, making just eight appearances across a four-year stint at Goodison Park before leaving on a free. The more experienced Fabian Delph also struggled to overcome fitness problems and work his way to prominence.
By the end, the running joke was that the only way Everton could replace Gueye was to re-sign him from PSG… which they promptly did in summer 2022.
Another four years on, with Gueye having left again, this time as a 36-year-old free agent, the club face the same task.
Despite the additions of midfielders Hayden Hackney and Merlin Rohl, The Athletic reported earlier this month that a new central midfielder remains a priority for manager David Moyes and the club’s recruitment team.
Let’s take a look at how they might go about it, assessing some of the players they have studied and adding some data-led picks of our own.
What did Gueye bring? And what kind of profile do Everton want?
For most of his time at Everton, and indeed elsewhere, the Senegal international was known for his prolific ball-winning. He regularly topped Premier League-wide charts for tackles and interceptions, and was a key part of the team’s defensive setup.
Gueye was never, in the truest sense, a No 6. Rather than sitting in front of the defence and marking space, he was normally at his best when he was allowed to go looking for the ball and destroy opposition attacks.
But whether it was due to his age (he will be 37 in September), tactical tweaks, midfield partner James Garner’s development or a combination of at least some of the above, Gueye’s ball-winning did start to wane last season. Garner did the bulk of the defending and, as the below shows, the former Lille, Aston Villa and PSG man was instead given more license by Moyes to link play and break forward.

The big question Everton have to answer, then, is which version of Gueye are they actually trying to replace?
As The Athletic has reported, the early evidence is that they want a taller (Gueye is 5ft 8in/174cm), physically robust player to complement their existing options. Should they get one, it would potentially allow them to go for a smaller, more attack-minded option at right-back and balance the team out in a different way.
Everton’s new midfielder needs to be comfortable playing predominantly in a 4-2-3-1, but also in a 4-3-3 or with a back three at times. They often defend man-to-man under Moyes, so the ability to cover ground is also key.
Gueye left Everton earlier this summer for the second time in his career (Molly Darlington/Getty Images)
The manager wants to make his side more technically sound, but last season they averaged one of the lowest possession shares in the Premier League. Ideally, this new midfielder would be a progressive passer — something Everton also see in Hackney — who helps in possession, but can also distribute in a more direct manner at times.
Given their need for a plug-and-play option rather than someone they can develop, we have prioritised players in Europe’s top leagues and the second-tier Championship, which also fits with Everton’s recent recruitment strategy.
Last season’s key target: Joao Palhinha
If Everton want a pure destroyer, there are few better than the Bayern Munich man. They courted him last summer before his loan move to Tottenham Hotspur.
Standing at 6ft 3in and boasting both Premier League and international pedigree, the 31-year-old Portugal international has the height and physicality to make his mark in front of a defence. He is competent rather than spectacular on the ball, and was a threat for Tottenham in the final third, particularly from set pieces, as he showed in scoring against Everton on the final day of the campaign in May.

Palhinha has rejected Everton once and would be a tough target to obtain if they try again. Aston Villa have also shown an interest in him this summer, and can offer Champions League football, while he recently said he would like to stay at Bayern and fight for his place after Spurs decided against triggering the €30million (£25.7m/$34.6m at the current rates) option contained in his loan deal.
The Athletic has reported that the German champions would be open to a sale at the right price.
Mandela Keita — next cab off the rank?
Everton are one of several teams to have followed the progress of Parma’s Belgium international Mandela Keita.
As the below playstyle wheel shows, the 24-year-old is an active presence off the ball and relatively adept both at retaining possession and ball-carrying.

Like Gueye, Keita offers little in the final third. He rarely creates or gets into threatening positions and, at 5ft 11in, is shorter than Palhinha.
He would represent more of a risk from an adaptation standpoint than someone like the Portuguese, who has made over 100 Premier League appearances for Fulham and Spurs, something that may well deter Everton, but has an interesting profile and, at that age, plenty of upside.
Mandela Keita of Parma has been capped once by Belgium (Emmanuele Ciancaglini/Getty Images)
Another Gueye?
After playing starring roles alongside namesake Idrissa Gueye for Senegal in the Africa Cup of Nations at the turn of the year and then the World Cup, Villarreal’s Pape Gueye was linked with Everton earlier this summer.
While that reported interest is yet to be verified by The Athletic, sources in Spain, speaking on condition of anonymity to protect relationships, suggest the Paris-born 27-year-old could move this summer, with Villarreal keen to raise funds.

Gueye is a tall (around 6ft 2in), left-footed ball player who can progress the ball and knows where the net is, as his standout goals against Iraq this summer attest. He is strong in the tackle, but most of his other defensive numbers are on the lower side.
He is also expected to have interest from elsewhere and command a significant fee.
@fifaworldcup What a strike from Pape Gueye. 👏🇸🇳 #FIFAWorldCup ♬ som original – FIFA World Cup
Could Rios or Charles step up?
Everton have followed Colombia international Richard Rios since his days in Brazil with Palmeiras, and looked into a move last summer before he joined Portugal’s Benfica.
Rios is a dynamic, physically robust player who can operate in either the No 6 or No 8 position. He averaged 9.2 ‘true tackles’ (tackles+challenges lost+fouls committed) in last season’s Champions League, placing him in the top 20 per cent of all central midfielders in that category.
Standing at 6ft 1in, he blends that physicality with a box-to-box style and technical ability honed playing futsal earlier in his career. It remains to be seen, though, whether Benfica would sell only a year into his deal.
Southampton’s Shea Charles has also been tracked — both during his time in the youth ranks at Manchester City, before the acquisition of Garner, and last season in the Championship. A natural No 6 or No 8, the 22-year-old Northern Ireland international is competitive out of possession and capable of striding forward, evading challenges and joining the attack.

Earlier this summer, though, the club instead chose to prioritise a move for fellow second-division star Hackney.
What the data says
Based on the profile outlined above, The Athletic’s Mark Carey has highlighted three potential targets.
Freiburg’s Maximilian Eggestein is an experienced ball-winner capable of contributing in the final third. He fits the bill in being able to immediately slot in but, at 29 (30 in December), offers little resale value.

Wolves’ 24-year-old Mali international Boubacar Traore had a successful loan at Metz in France’s Ligue 1 last season and stands out defensively…

… while 6ft 2in former Sheffield United midfielder Vinicius Souza, 27, who is now at Wolfsburg in Germany’s second tier, is effective in ground and aerial duels.

Could one of these players do the job?
Whoever Everton end up with, he will need to fare much better than the midfielder signed the last time they were replacing Gueye.
Get this right, and there is the opportunity to give the team a new dimension entirely. Get it wrong, and Moyes’ side may well end up on less certain foundations than before.
>
Sports
Katie Boulter to lead Great Britain team at Billie Jean King Cup finals
Katie Boulter will lead the British team at the Billie Jean Cup Finals in Shenzhen, China.
Emma Raducanu, who has struggled with injury and illness throughout the year, has not been named in the squad.
British number two Boulter replaces Katie Swan in a team that is otherwise unchanged from their qualifying win against Australia, in Harriet Dart, Mika Stojsavljevic and Jodie Burrage.
Britain begin their campaign against the Czech Republic on Tuesday, 22 September.
In April, 17-year-old Stojsavljevic starred with a singles win over world number 56 Talia Gibson as Britain upset the home side in Melbourne to qualify for their fourth finals in five years.
“I’m pleased to select Katie Boulter, who knows what it’s like to step up on occasions like this, and the three women who played with so much heart and courage to upset Australia earlier this year,” said Great Britain captain Anne Keothavong.
“Czechia will be a very challenging first match for us but the players and I believe in our chances, since we have a very strong record in recent finals.”
Wimbledon champion Linda Noskova and runner-up Karolina Muchova are in the team for 11-time winners Czechia, who Britain face in the quarter-finals.
World number two Elena Rybakina will lead Kazakhstan, who play Spain, while Olympic champion Zheng Qinwen leads hosts China as they challenge defending champions Italy, featuring Olympic doubles gold pair Jasmine Paolini and Sara Errani.
Ukraine and Belgium complete the last-eight line-up, with all ties at the finals to be decided in a best-of-three format of two singles and one doubles.
>
Sports
League has ‘genuine concern’ for club members over cheating claim
An amateur cricket league has expressed its “genuine concern for the welfare” of Saltburn Cricket Club members over a recent finger clicking controversy that has made global headlines.
The North Yorkshire and South Durham Cricket League spoke out in the wake of worldwide interest in an alleged incident that has led to a player being suspended by the club.
That happened after a video from the second XI Division 2 game involving Saltburn and Norton went viral on social media.
The video appeared to show Saltburn fielder Brian Devine clicking his fingers in order to trick the umpire into giving a Norton batter out.
On Monday, the North Yorkshire and South Durham Cricket League began an investigation into Devine, who has been suspended by Saltburn for the “foreseeable future”.
The league said it is treating allegations of cheating “with the utmost seriousness”, and in a statement on Friday called for the “rights of all parties” to be observed in the face of intense scrutiny on social media.
“We would want to place on record our genuine concern for the welfare for those at Saltburn Cricket Club and ask for all to take that into account – there are many people at the club and one of our aims will be to provide them with any wellbeing support we can,” the league said.
“Whilst we understand, to some degree, the interest this issue has generated in the press and media, it is imperative that now this process is under way that the rights of all parties are observed, including the overriding principles of natural justice and a right to a fair hearing for any individual or any entity concerned.
“Anything less risks prejudicing any formal actions which may follow.”
The incident has been dubbed ‘Clicky Ponting’ – a pun on the name of former Australia captain Ricky Ponting.
Saltburn, in their own statement on Wednesday, said: “We believe that the club acted decisively as soon as the complaint and investigation were made known to us.
“The player at the centre of the complaint has been suspended and will not play again for the club this season or in the forseeable future, pending the outcome of this investigation.”
That statement added: “This has been a very distressing and stressful experience for all those concerned, and we would ask that this reality is borne in mind and that personal boundaries are respected, as we are an amateur club entirely run by volunteers.”
>
Sports
Rob Key leaves door open for Ben Stokes to make England Test return
Rob Key has left the door open for Ben Stokes to return to the England side for next year’s Ashes series, with the England and Wales Cricket Board’s (ECB) managing director for men’s cricket admitting he considered his own position after a tumultuous summer.
Stokes gave up the captaincy and abruptly retired from international cricket as his side slipped to defeat in the third Test against New Zealand last month, a loss that saw the series surrendered 2-1, with Brendon McCullum subsequently sacked as head coach of the England red-ball team.
However, speaking to the media on Friday after playing a key role in the appointment of Stokes’ and McCullum’s successors, Joe Root and Stephen Fleming, Key did not rule out the possibility of Stokes returning to the side in future.
When asked if he had discussed a Stokes comeback with Fleming with one eye on the visit of Australia next summer, Key said: “We haven’t got round to that at the moment, but it would be a great story.”
Asked by Sky Sports if Stokes himself had suggested coming back, Key said: “No, he hasn’t but I wouldn’t be surprised. Anything’s possible with Ben.“
Further pressed on whether bridges had been burned with Stokes, Key added: “No, not at all. Not as far as I’m concerned.”
Rob Key has come under pressure since England’s Ashes debacle over the winter (Gareth Copley/Getty Images)
Key admitted he had considered his own position after the 4-1 defeat to Australia in the Ashes over the winter, questions around a drinking culture in the England side with Stokes, vice-captain Harry Brook and other players involved in various controversies, and this summer’s series loss to New Zealand which prompted the departures of McCullum and Stokes.
“I think all of the above,” Key said, when asked if he had thought about stepping down, or whether he feared he would be sacked.
“Of course you do (consider your position). This is a job where you’re constantly under pressure all the time. There’s uncertainty in it all the time. That’s part of being in this role. How close I came (to being sacked), I don’t know. How close I came myself (to resigning), what I was thinking, I obviously know.
“But it’s been a good few months — and even before that — where you’re constantly thinking, ‘Are you the right person? What is the thing you’ve got to do? Are you the person to put that in place?’ I believe I am, but that’s for the people above me to decide all the time.”
England confirmed the appointment of Fleming and Root as new Test head coach and captain this week. Key explained that it was “too soon” for Brook, who had been vice-captain under Stokes and leads the England white-ball teams, to take on the Test role too — particularly with a 50-over World Cup to come next year.
He will continue to work under McCullum, who retained his position as white-ball coach.
“Harry’s still developing as a player and as a person,” Key said. “The Test match captaincy is the biggest job in cricket in England. Harry can now continue on the project he’s done in the white-ball job and continue learning how to become an outstanding leader of a cricket team.
“At some stage Harry Brook will be an outstanding Test captain of England cricket. I just didn’t feel the time was right now.”
Harry Brook has forged a strong relationship with the white-ball coach Brendon McCullum (Oli Scarff/AFP via Getty Images)
Key said that details are still being worked out on when exactly Fleming will start work, but it definitely would not be for the upcoming home series against Pakistan. Key said that it would have “narrowed the field considerably” if availability for that series was a stipulation for the job: assistant coach Marcus Trescothick will lead the side for those games on an interim basis.
“(Fleming) will first come over in September, sometime like that,” said Key. “We’re already speaking all the time, every opportunity we have. He’s speaking with Joe, Marcus (North, the selector), starting to really get into as much as he can, the ins and outs of our setup.
“He knows English cricket really well. He’s been close to it. He’s obviously played in it. He has a huge amount of love and respect for the county game in particular — what it did for him as a player and part of his development. So as much as he’ll be over in September, he’s already very much in the weeds of it all.”
Stephen Fleming enjoyed an 18-year association with Chennai Super Kings (Prakash Singh/Getty Images)
Fleming has spent all of his coaching career so far in franchise white-ball cricket — mainly with the Chennai Super Kings, with whom he won the Indian Premier League five times — and is currently at home in New Zealand spending time with his family.
Key confirmed the incoming head coach will have some “input” into selection for the Pakistan Tests, and also contributed to the decision to return to Root, who previously captained England from 2017 to 2022.
>
-
movies2 months agoSearch For Canadian TV Actor Stewart McLean Now Homicide Investigation
-
Fashion9 years agoThese ’90s fashion trends are making a comeback in 2017
-
Fashion9 years agoAccording to Dior Couture, this taboo fashion accessory is back
-
Fashion9 years agoModel Jocelyn Chew’s Instagram is the best vacation you’ve ever had
-
Fashion9 years agoYour comprehensive guide to this fall’s biggest trends
-
Fashion9 years ago9 Celebrities who have spoken out about being photoshopped
-
Fashion9 years agoEmily Ratajkowski channels back-to-school style
-
Fashion9 years agoA photo diary of the nightlife scene from LA To Ibiza
