Connect with us

Sports

It’s time to throw the red flag on NFL challenges. Why are they needed at all?

Published

on

The NFL is changing its challenge system this season. Maybe instead, it’s time to challenge the challenges.

For the first time since the red flag challenge system was introduced in 1999, head coaches can now designate an assistant coach or staff member as the official flag bearer. It’s reasonable to wonder why we need them at all.

Before the two-minute warning, coaches have exclusive authority to force formal reviews over many ordinary plays. After the warning, that authority flips: coaches are barred from challenging, and the replay official alone decides what deserves another look. If the league trusts the booth when the stakes are highest, why not use the same system for the other 28 minutes?

When coaches first began tucking red flags in their socks and were instructed to throw them on the field whenever they were unhappy with the officiating, the world was panicking over a potential Y2K computer crash. That’s how long we’ve been doing this. Former coaches like Dick Vermeil, Ray Rhodes, Bruce Coslet and Mike Ditka were carrying red flags long before dating apps turned them into pop-culture slang.

Roger Goodell on technology and officials

Mike Jones

A lack of technology may have made them necessary back when replay review was antiquated and cumbersome. We have reached an age when NFL replay officials in New York can monitor every available broadcast angle from every game across the country within seconds.

Regardless of who is throwing the flag, the NFL requires teams to spot a mistake, grab a handkerchief, find an official before the ball is snapped again and wager one of their timeouts against whether the referees got a call wrong.

Coaches have essentially become trial attorneys: File the right motion, at the right time and on the correct grounds, or have the entire case thrown out.

Detroit Lions coach Dan Campbell correctly believed the Los Angeles Rams’ Colby Parkinson was down at the 4-yard line in a December game last year and challenged the spot when officials instead placed the ball at the 3.

But a spot is only reviewable when it impacts a first down or touchdown. Parkinson caught a short pass from Matthew Stafford on first-and-10 and turned it into a big play. Since the disputed yard did not affect whether the Rams gained a first down, officials ruled the spot was not challengeable and charged the Lions with a timeout. Replay assistance corrected the call, and officials placed the ball at the 4 anyway — but still took a timeout away from Detroit.

“I won the challenge, but I lost my timeout,” Campbell said.

Football is uniquely suited for an official-led system because every play is followed by a built-in review window. The play clock gives a replay official time to examine what just happened while teams huddle, substitute and prepare for the next snap. Correcting an obvious mistake during that window often wouldn’t require an additional stoppage.

More fundamentally, enforcing the rules should remain the league’s responsibility. A receiver’s foot was either out of bounds or it wasn’t. A runner’s knee was either down or it wasn’t. Those facts shouldn’t change because one coach had a timeout available, recognized the mistake or employed a better replay staff than his opponent.

The NFL already accepts that principle on scores, turnovers, failed fourth downs, and during the final two minutes. Those plays aren’t automatically reviewed because replay officials suddenly become more capable when the stakes rise. They’re reviewed because the league has decided those calls are too important to leave to coaching strategy. A mistake in the first quarter is no less wrong.

Keep automatic reviews for scores, turnovers and failed fourth downs. For other reviewable plays, transfer the authority to initiate corrections from coaches to the replay official. Give a dedicated replay decision-maker assigned to each game a limited window to correct clear, objective errors.

That would require one dedicated decision-maker for every game, rather than supervisors juggling several games at once. No problem. The NFL can afford the staffing.

If the replay official needs additional time to check an angle, he should have the authority to signal the referee and briefly delay the snap. The delay could be capped — maybe no more than 20 seconds. Replay should correct the obvious, not provide time for New York to launch an investigation.

Such a system might create an occasional brief delay, but it should eliminate most lengthy replay stoppages. The NFL is already monitoring every play.

Baseball offers a useful model for making the final decision: MLB’s replay umpire in New York makes the ruling and relays it to the crew chief. The on-field umpires don’t review the evidence themselves. The NFL doesn’t need to bring a tablet onto the field for an expedited correction. Make the call in New York, relay it to the referee and play on.

It would eliminate the coach-triggered formal reviews and sideline theater that occur when coaches run down the field with a flag while assistants scream into their headsets. Or moments such as Thursday night, when New England Patriots coach Mike Vrabel played long toss with his flag to protest a fumble call.

Why should coaches have to weigh whether a first-quarter officiating error is important enough to risk a timeout? Getting a call right shouldn’t depend on whether a coach is willing to make a bet.

The NFL has tried a booth-driven system before. From 1986 through 1991, replay supervisors decided which plays warranted review. The league dumped it amid complaints about delays and frustration that teams had no way to request a review.

Technology has evolved quite a bit since the late 1980s. Video was primitive, and the process was excruciatingly slow. Now replay officials can view synchronized, high-definition angles through Hawk-Eye Innovations and communicate directly with officials on the field. The concept wasn’t necessarily wrong; it just arrived about 35 years too soon.

Tennis has largely eliminated human line judges in favor of the same Hawk-Eye system for line calls. Soccer uses its own version of Hawk-Eye for goal-line technology and semi-automated offside technology.

The obvious objection is that the replay official may occasionally miss something a coach would have challenged. Of course that could happen. But the NFL already removes the coaches’ role during the final two minutes, precisely when a missed call can do the most damage. If booth-only authority is sufficient during a winning drive, it should be sufficient in the first quarter, too.

The speed at which these games are played makes perfect officiating impossible. No one is demanding perfection, but rather giving them a little help from the sky when they need it. We shouldn’t need a red flag to do it.

>

Continue Reading

Sports

What we learned from the Commanders’ preseason win over the Dolphins

Published

on

LANDOVER, Md. — Consider this the ramp-up period. The Commanders opened their preseason on Friday with a 20-7 win over the Miami Dolphins, a rebuilding team sorely lacking talent and depth on both sides of the ball.

The win may not directly foreshadow the Commanders’ season ahead, but there was plenty to glean as coach Dan Quinn and general manager Adam Peters continue to evaluate the roster.

Quinn has stressed competition throughout camp (and, really, throughout his two-plus seasons in Washington), but many starting jobs are clearly taken, leaving the uncertainty primarily with the reserves.

Washington sat 26 veteran players, most of whom are locks to start this season. Quarterback Jayden Daniels was among them, as were veteran receivers Terry McLaurin and Stefon Diggs.

The focus was on the twos and threes (and at some positions, the fours, fives, sixes and sevens) battling for roster spots. Here’s what we learned from the Commanders’ preseason opener.

Commanders feeling whiplash with addition of Diggs, loss of Tunsil

Nicki Jhabvala

Marcus Mariota got hurt

Washington’s backup quarterback was slated to play only one drive , but he left four plays into it with an apparent non-contact injury.

Mariota went down after handing the ball off to rookie running back Kaytron Allen on a first-and-10 from Miami’s 47-yard line. Mariota pointed to his right knee as athletic trainers ran onto the field, but he quickly popped up and walked off on his own.

Mariota was briefly examined in the medical tent, then walked back to the locker room with assistant head athletic trainer Mark McCracken.

Quinn said after the game that he did not have an update on Mariota’s status (teams are not required to disclose injuries in preseason) but expects to know more in the next couple of days. The team’s next practice with media availability is Tuesday.

Sam Hartman took over for Mariota and played the remainder of the first half, plus the first drive of the third quarter, before turning the offense over to undrafted rookie Athan Kaliakmanis. Hartman was 5-of-8 passing for 80 yards with one interception, while Kaliakmanis was 6-of-10 for 87 yards. Neither quarterback threw a touchdown.

A slow start but a quick rebound

The Dolphins opened with a 14-play, 93-yard scoring drive — after muffing the kickoff and getting flagged for holding on the return. It was hardly the showing Washington hoped for after overhauling its defense in the offseason.

The Commanders’ defensive line featured all reserves, but Sonny Styles and Leo Chenal started at linebacker, and the secondary included safeties Will Harris and Quan Martin, along with veteran corner Rasul Douglas. That they couldn’t stop a Miami team lacking in playmakers and depth was alarming, but Washington quickly regrouped.

After their opening score (a one-yard run by De’Von Achane), the Dolphins never made it past Washington’s 45-yard line and ended their subsequent drives with a turnover on downs, an interception, six consecutive punts and two interceptions.

Defensive tackles Johnny Newton and Ricky Barber stuffed quarterback Quinn Ewers on a fourth-down run in the first quarter, then Quan Martin picked him off for the first of Washington’s three interceptions. Linebacker Ale Kaho and safety Malik Spencer had the others.

Cornerback Antonio Hamilton also bounced back after getting flagged for pass interference on Miami’s scoring drive (the penalty was declined). He landed a huge hit on Jalen Reagor during a kickoff return, then knocked the ball loose when he hit Tahj Washington on a pass play in the final seconds of the first half.

Hamilton is among the corners fighting for a spot that may or may not exist on the initial 53-man roster. The top four at the position are presumably Trey Amos, Mike Sainristil, Amik Robertson and Douglas. If Washington keeps a fifth corner, or if injury necessitates a replacement, Hamilton may have a shot.

The young backs shined

Jacory “Bill” Croskey-Merritt, Rachaad White and Jeremy McNichols (quad injury) were all inactive, leaving Washington’s run game primarily in the hands of its two rookies, Kaytron Allen and Robert Henry Jr. And they didn’t disappoint.

Allen, a sixth-round draft pick, collected a game-high 85 rushing yards on 23 carries, including a one-yard touchdown run with 11 seconds left in the second quarter.

Allen began the game with a handful of short runs, but he broke free for a 16-yard carry late in the second quarter. The spark, he said, was watching his fellow rookie break away for Washington’s first touchdown earlier in the quarter.

“When Rob got a little run, I feel like he got me going,” Allen said. “Seeing him get one made me get one.”

Henry, an undrafted back out of UTSA, displayed his shiftiness, patience and vision behind the line, totaling 75 yards on 12 carries for an average of 6.3 yards per carry. Half of his yardage came on two runs in the second quarter, when he weaved through the middle of the line for a 15-yard gain, then capped the drive with a 22-yard touchdown run. Henry took the handoff from Hartman, faked going inside, then cut right and sprinted up the sideline for the score.

Henry also returned a kickoff 30 yards at the start of the third quarter.

His play Friday night was reminiscent of his final season at UTSA, when he topped 1,000 rushing yards and averaged 156 in the first four games.

“I liked the backs,” Quinn said. “They’re in shape. They were focused. They were ready. And like I said, when they came out to be a little shorthanded, there was no flinch. That was a good sign to me.”

Quan Martin has a strong showing

The Commanders’ initial depth chart, which Quinn joked is as valuable as preseason rankings, lists Jeremy Reaves and Martin as co-No. 1s at free safety.

Reaves was among the 26 inactive players on Friday, while Martin played the entire first half.

Martin’s place on the roster remains uncertain, despite starting 32 of the Commanders’ last 34 games. Last season, he had a 154.6 passer rating against, the fourth-highest among NFL defenders with at least 200 coverage snaps. He also missed 15 tackles, the second-most on the Commanders behind Frankie Luvu’s 21.

Martin was benched in the team’s Week 11 loss to the Dolphins in Madrid, and logged only six defensive snaps in the team’s season-ending loss to the Philadelphia Eagles.

Washington signed veteran safety Nick Cross as a free agent in March and has another year with Will Harris. Tyler Owens and Percy Butler are also back and, like Reaves, have been core special-teamers for Washington.

To say Martin needed a strong showing on Friday would be an understatement. He delivered, with a body-slamming tackle of Achane during Miami’s first drive, then the interception on a third-and-7 early in the second quarter.

Commanders safety Quan Martin celebrates after securing an interception in Washington's preseason win over the Dolphins.

Commanders safety Quan Martin celebrates after securing an interception in Washington’s preseason win over the Dolphins. (Scott Taetsch / Getty Images)

“I think in this profession, in life, I think we all kind of go through some things, but it’s all about our response, man,” he said. “I think I responded great, and I just kind of know what I want out of this season, and now I just want to have an impact on the team.”

Quinn said Reaves and Cross are expected to play in the second preseason game, and indicated it’s possible Martin will be inactive or take fewer defensive snaps.

A little bit of Style

First-round rookie Sonny Styles started and played only one series — the 14-play, 93-yard scoring drive by Miami. Styles’ sample size was miniscule, but he had a run stuff and flashed his speed. He also wore the green dot, as the on-field quarterback of the defense tasked with relaying plays in the huddle.

Styles said he and Chenal asked to play another series to flush the 14-play scoring drive by Miami, but Quinn didn’t veer from his plan.

Drew Stevens still leads

The undrafted rookie Stevens and incumbent kicker Jake Moody are still competing and alternated kicks and kickoffs on Friday. Although they had a field goal apiece, Stevens seems to have a strong lead over Moody, who has had a slew of misses in recent training camp practices.

Moody doinked a 29-yard attempt off the upright, but the ball went through. Stevens booted a 41-yarder and nailed an extra-point attempt.

Put 5 on it

I honestly thought I’d see way more of these jerseys at Northwest Stadium after Daniels dominated headlines because of the cease-and-desist letter he sent to LSU earlier this month. But nope. Just saw this guy.

Change of tune

Over the three years since Josh Harris and his group of 20 limited partners purchased the team from former owner Dan Snyder, the Commanders have paid tribute to the team’s past through nearly every facet of the organization, from the latest uniform change to the design of its future stadium in D.C. Last year, the team introduced a pregame show that aired in the stadium before kickoff and attempted to create more of an identity for the Commanders name, which it adopted in 2022 after 87 years as the Redskins.

During the rebranding process, former team president Jason Wright wrote on the team’s website that engaging with Native American leaders and individuals “demonstrated to us a consensus that moving forward with no ties to Native American imagery is the right path.” Although some fans preferred the nickname Warriors as a replacement for Redskins, Wright said that “an embrace of potentially Native-adjacent iconography and imagery would not represent a clear departure that many communities have so forcefully advocated for us to embrace, and that frankly, we set out to do when we started this process …”

But on Friday, the team not so subtly restored one piece of Native-adjacent imagery by restoring the line “Braves on a warpath” to its fight song. The line had been replaced with “Fight for our Commanders” after the name change.

>

Continue Reading

Sports

How to watch Yankees vs. Blue Jays: TV channel and streaming options for August 15

Published

on

The New York Yankees visit the Toronto Blue Jays on Saturday at Rogers Centre, at 3:07 p.m. ET. Cam Schlittler (10-6, 2.21 ERA) gets the start for the Yankees, who are 68-54 this season and second in the AL East. Braydon Fisher (3-3, 3.54 ERA) is starting for the Blue Jays, who are 60-64 and fourth in the AL East.

How to watch New York Yankees vs. Toronto Blue Jays

Yankees vs. Blue Jays odds

  • Favorite Moneyline: Yankees -169
  • Underdog Moneyline: Blue Jays +140
  • Total: 7.5
  • Total Over Odds: +100
  • Total Under Odds: -120

Injury reports

Yankees

Giancarlo Stanton: 10 Day IL (Leg), Cody Bellinger: 10 Day IL (Leg), Carlos Rodon: 15 Day IL (Elbow), Kervin Castro: 15 Day IL (Elbow), Aaron Judge: 60 Day IL (Rib), Clarke Schmidt: 60 Day IL (Elbow)

Blue Jays

Luis Urias: 10 Day IL (Quadricep), Jonatan Clase: 10 Day IL (Foot), Spencer Arrighetti: 15 Day IL (Foot), Jameson Taillon: 15 Day IL (Forearm), Trey Yesavage: 15 Day IL (Knee), Cody Ponce: 60 Day IL (Knee), Anthony Santander: 60 Day IL (Shoulder), Jake Bloss: 60 Day IL (Elbow), Bowden Francis: 60 Day IL (Elbow), Joe Mantiply: 60 Day IL (Knee), Addison Barger: 60 Day IL (Elbow), Yimi Garcia: 60 Day IL (Elbow), José Berrios: 60 Day IL (Elbow), Lenyn Sosa: 60 Day IL (Wrist), Patrick Corbin: 60 Day IL (Shoulder), Vladimir Guerrero Jr.: day-to-day (Head)

Stats to know

  • New York’s Ben Rice has hit 32 home runs this season, which ranks 6th in MLB. He has also tallied 76 RBIs (12th in MLB) and has scored 75 runs. In 500 plate appearances, he has recorded a .253 BA, .348 OBP and .535 SLG with a 12.2% walk rate and a 25% strikeout rate.
  • In 411 plate appearances, Luis Garcia is hitting .278/.309/.546 with a .855 OPS. He has hit 24 long balls (20th in MLB), driven in 78 runs (7th in MLB) and scored 51 times.
  • Toronto’s Ernie Clement is slashing .280/.306/.403 this season with nine home runs, 42 RBIs and an OPS of .709. He has a 9.7% strikeout rate and a 3.5% walk rate in 487 plate appearances, and he has scored 50 total runs.
  • In 486 plate appearances, Vladimir Guerrero Jr. has posted a 13.4% strikeout rate and a 9.7% walk rate while slashing .263/.337/.356 with seven home runs, 46 RBIs and 61 runs scored. He has stolen seven bases on 10 attempts.

This watch guide was created using technology provided by Data Skrive.

Betting/odds, ticketing and streaming links in this article are provided by partners of The Athletic. Restrictions may apply. The Athletic maintains full editorial independence. Partners have no control over or input into the reporting or editing process and do not review stories before publication.

Photo: Jamie Squire, Ishika Samant, Scott Taetsch, Alika Jenner / Getty Images

Connections: Sports Edition Logo

Connections: Sports Edition Logo

Connections: Sports Edition

Spot the pattern. Connect the terms

Find the hidden link between sports terms

>

Continue Reading

Sports

How to watch Cardinals vs. Cubs: TV channel and streaming options for August 15

Published

on

The Chicago Cubs and St. Louis Cardinals clash on Saturday at 2:20 p.m. ET. Matthew Boyd (8-1, 3.50 ERA) gets the start for the Cubs, who are 72-51 this season and second in the NL Central. Michael McGreevy (4-9, 3.64 ERA) is the expected starter for the Cardinals, who are 61-61 and third in the NL Central.

How to watch St. Louis Cardinals vs. Chicago Cubs

Cardinals vs. Cubs odds

  • Favorite Moneyline: Cubs -182
  • Underdog Moneyline: Cardinals +150
  • Total: 9.5
  • Total Over Odds: +100
  • Total Under Odds: -120

Injury reports

Cubs

Matt Shaw: 10 Day IL (Hand), Daniel Palencia: 15 Day IL (Elbow), Hoby Milner: 15 Day IL (Appendicitis), Gavin Hollowell: 15 Day IL (Shoulder), Phil Maton: 15 Day IL (Knee), Edward Cabrera: 15 Day IL (Hamstring), Riley Martin: 60 Day IL (Elbow), Porter Hodge: 60 Day IL (Elbow), Justin Steele: 60 Day IL (Elbow), Shelby Miller: 60 Day IL (Elbow), Hunter Harvey: 60 Day IL (Tricep), Cade Horton: 60 Day IL (Forearm), Christopher Austin: 60 Day IL (Knee), Ben Brown: 60 Day IL (Neck)

Cardinals

Ramón Urías: 60 Day IL (Elbow), Max Rajcic: 60 Day IL (Elbow)

Stats to know

  • Chicago’s Pete Crow-Armstrong is slashing .279/.378/.534 this season with 27 home runs (9th in MLB), 73 RBIs (17th in MLB) and an OPS of .912 (7th in MLB). He has a 27.1% strikeout rate and an 11.9% walk rate in 546 plate appearances, and he has scored 86 total runs. Crow-Armstrong has recorded 30 steals on 37 attempts.
  • In 549 plate appearances, Alex Bregman has slashed .253/.344/.406 this season. He has hit 16 long balls and driven in 61 runs with a strikeout rate of 15.8% and a walk rate of 11.1%. He has come around to score 69 times.
  • Alec Burleson has hit 19 home runs this season. He has also tallied 84 RBIs (4th in MLB) and has scored 65 runs. In 512 plate appearances, he has recorded a .285 BA, .352 OBP and .478 SLG with an 8.6% walk rate and a 16.4% strikeout rate.
  • In 503 plate appearances, Jordan Walker has hit 23 long balls, tallied 84 RBIs (4th in MLB) and scored 72 runs. He is batting .282/.342/.486 and has posted a 24.5% strikeout rate and an 8% walk rate. Walker has recorded 16 steals on 21 attempts.

This watch guide was created using technology provided by Data Skrive.

Betting/odds, ticketing and streaming links in this article are provided by partners of The Athletic. Restrictions may apply. The Athletic maintains full editorial independence. Partners have no control over or input into the reporting or editing process and do not review stories before publication.

Photo: Jamie Squire, Ishika Samant, Scott Taetsch, Alika Jenner / Getty Images

Connections: Sports Edition Logo

Connections: Sports Edition Logo

Connections: Sports Edition

Spot the pattern. Connect the terms

Find the hidden link between sports terms

>

Continue Reading

Trending

Copyright © 2017 Zox News Theme. Theme by MVP Themes, powered by WordPress.